David Manthey

Q: What is David Manthey's success rate?

David Manthey currently has a success rate of 91.96454688117659.

Q: What is the average return of David Manthey's calls?

Their stock ratings have generated an average return of 7.790519559427143.

Baird | Industrials

David Manthey is an analyst from Baird specializing in the Industrials sector. Ranked #1850 out of 4771 analysts, they have issued 15 stock ratings with a success rate of 91.96% and an average return of 7.79%.

With 15 ratings to date, David Manthey is beginning to establish credibility in the Industrials sector. They have achieved a success rate of 91.96% and an average return of 7.79%, highlighting promising potential as their track record develops further.

#1850

Out of 4771

Total Ratings

+91.96%

Success Rate

+7.79%

Average Return

Recent Ratings Analysis

WSO

Buy

Jul 28, 2026

Target

$420.00

Current

$310.90

Performance

-15.40%

David Manthey rated WSO as Outperform on Jul 28, 2026, setting a price target of 420. The stock has underperformed, dropping 15.40% despite the bullish target of 420.

SITE

Buy

Jul 28, 2026

Target

$155.00

Current

$94.78

Performance

-8.40%

On Jul 28, 2026, SITE was given a Outperform rating by David Manthey, with a target price of 155. Despite the Buy call, shares fell from 94.78 to 94.78, challenging the optimistic stance.

QXO

Buy

May 13, 2026

Target

$30.00

Current

$12.29

Performance

-27.79%

QXO received a Outperform rating from David Manthey on May 13, 2026, aiming for 30. The rating hasn’t played out as hoped, with the stock trading 27.79% below expectations.

WM

Buy

Apr 16, 2026

Target

$260.00

Current

$214.77

Performance

-4.15%

On Apr 16, 2026, David Manthey published a Outperform outlook on WM, with a target of 260. So far, the stock has neither confirmed nor rejected the Buy case, holding within range of 214.77.

RSG

Hold

Apr 16, 2026

Target

$240.00

Current

$221.08

Performance

5.45%

David Manthey on Apr 16, 2026 assigned RSG a Neutral rating, with a price target of 240. Shares outperformed expectations, climbing 5.45% despite the neutral view.

CLH

Buy

Apr 16, 2026

Target

$350.00

Current

$320.94

Performance

8.20%

On Apr 16, 2026, David Manthey reaffirmed CLH with a Outperform rating, targeting 350. The recommendation was supported by strong follow-through as the stock rose from 320.94 to 320.94.

FAST

Buy

Apr 14, 2026

Target

$50.00

Current

$49.01

Performance

9.84%

FAST was rated Outperform by David Manthey on Apr 14, 2026, with a price objective of 50. A bullish response from the market helped close the gap of 0.99 to the target.

POOL

Buy

Feb 20, 2026

Target

$320.00

Current

$175.76

Performance

-20.69%

On Feb 20, 2026, David Manthey initiated coverage on POOL with a Outperform rating and target of 320. The Buy call has yet to be validated as shares remain 144.24 away from the target.

BLDR

Hold

Feb 18, 2026

Target

$135.00

Current

$58.97

Performance

-48.23%

David Manthey issued a Neutral recommendation for BLDR on Feb 18, 2026, price target set at 135. Market action validated the conservative Hold outlook with shares at 58.97.

FERG

Buy

Dec 10, 2025

Target

$265.00

Current

$220.97

Performance

-4.47%

On Dec 10, 2025, FERG was evaluated by David Manthey, who gave a Outperform rating and target of 265. So far, the Buy call awaits clearer momentum, with shares flat at 220.97.

CNM

Buy

Dec 10, 2025

Target

$64.00

Current

$40.85

Performance

-26.00%

David Manthey rated CNM as Outperform on Dec 10, 2025, setting a price target of 64. The stock has underperformed, dropping 26.00% despite the bullish target of 64.

AIT

Buy

Aug 15, 2025

Target

$300.00

Current

$318.58

Performance

24.93%

On Aug 15, 2025, AIT was given a Outperform rating by David Manthey, with a target price of 300. The stock rallied 24.93% after the rating, narrowing the gap to the target of 300 and validating the bullish stance.

MSM

Hold

Jul 02, 2025

Target

$95.00

Current

$119.68

Performance

33.56%

MSM received a Neutral rating from David Manthey on Jul 02, 2025, aiming for 95. Investors saw gains of 33.56% that the cautious stance didn’t fully capture.

GMS

Hold

Jun 23, 2025

Target

$95.00

Current

$109.96

Performance

9.51%

On Jun 23, 2025, David Manthey published a Neutral outlook on GMS, with a target of 95. The Hold call missed some of the bullish momentum as shares advanced toward 95.

BECN

Buy

Feb 28, 2025

Target

$124.00

Current

$124.17

Performance

7.58%

David Manthey on Feb 28, 2025 assigned BECN a Outperform rating, with a price target of 124. The Buy call aligned well with market performance, producing a gain of 7.58%.

HLMN

Buy

Feb 19, 2025

Target

$12.00

Current

$6.98

Performance

-31.84%

On Feb 19, 2025, David Manthey reaffirmed HLMN with a Outperform rating, targeting 12. Shares slid 31.84% despite the recommendation, highlighting downside risks.

GWW

Buy

Oct 16, 2024

Target

$1230.00

Current

$1271.49

Performance

14.25%

GWW was rated Outperform by David Manthey on Oct 16, 2024, with a price objective of 1230. A bullish response from the market helped close the gap of -41.49 to the target.

WCC

Hold

Aug 02, 2024

Target

$172.00

Current

$344.00

Performance

124.22%

On Aug 02, 2024, David Manthey initiated coverage on WCC with a Neutral rating and target of 172. The Hold stance underestimated the stock’s strength as it gained 124.22%.

SRCL

Hold

Apr 26, 2024

Target

$55.00

Current

$61.98

Performance

33.84%

David Manthey issued a Neutral recommendation for SRCL on Apr 26, 2024, price target set at 55. A neutral call gave way to stronger-than-expected performance, closing in on 55.

Frequency Asked Questions

Who is David Manthey?

David Manthey is an analyst from Baird specializing in the Industrials sector.

What is David Manthey's success rate?

David Manthey currently has a success rate of +91.96%.

How many ratings has David Manthey issued?

David Manthey has issued 15 stock ratings so far.

What is the average return of David Manthey's calls?

Their stock ratings have generated an average return of +7.79%.

What is David Manthey's ranking?

David Manthey is ranked #1850 out of 4771 analysts.

What types of ratings does David Manthey give?

Their ratings include Buy, Hold, and Sell recommendations, depending on the stock’s outlook.

How can I follow David Manthey?

You can follow David Manthey by clicking the "Follow Analyst" button on this page to receive updates on their stock calls.

What is the most recent rating by David Manthey?

Their latest rating was a Buy on WSO issued on 2026-07-28.