John Baumgartner

Q: What is John Baumgartner's success rate?

John Baumgartner currently has a success rate of 92.02680549880566.

Q: What is the average return of John Baumgartner's calls?

Their stock ratings have generated an average return of 25.84248904504832.

Mizuho | Consumer Defensive

John Baumgartner is an analyst from Mizuho specializing in the Consumer Defensive sector. Ranked #1311 out of 4773 analysts, they have issued 31 stock ratings with a success rate of 92.03% and an average return of 25.84%.

John Baumgartner has a well-established track record, with 31 ratings issued in the Consumer Defensive sector. They have consistently delivered a success rate of 92.03% and an average return of 25.84%, underscoring their expertise and ability to identify winning opportunities for investors.

#1311

Out of 4773

Total Ratings

+92.03%

Success Rate

+25.84%

Average Return

Recent Ratings Analysis

LTH

Buy

Jul 31, 2026

Target

$64.00

Current

$41.50

Performance

-7.98%

John Baumgartner rated LTH as Outperform on Jul 31, 2026, setting a price target of 64. The stock has underperformed, dropping 7.98% despite the bullish target of 64.

HSY

Hold

May 20, 2026

Target

$185.00

Current

$173.32

Performance

-9.18%

On May 20, 2026, HSY was given a Neutral rating by John Baumgartner, with a target price of 185. The rating provided protection from downside risk as the stock fell to 173.32.

HLF

Hold

Mar 30, 2026

Target

$15.00

Current

$12.02

Performance

-16.59%

HLF received a Neutral rating from John Baumgartner on Mar 30, 2026, aiming for 15. The Hold stance proved prudent, with the market softening by 16.59%.

TSN

Buy

Mar 26, 2026

Target

$72.00

Current

$52.98

Performance

—

On Mar 26, 2026, John Baumgartner published a Outperform outlook on TSN, with a target of 72. So far, the stock has neither confirmed nor rejected the Buy case, holding within range of 52.98.

GIS

Hold

Mar 19, 2026

Target

$39.00

Current

$35.85

Performance

-4.40%

John Baumgartner on Mar 19, 2026 assigned GIS a Neutral rating, with a price target of 39. The Hold stance reflected consolidation, as shares held near 35.85.

BRBR

Buy

Mar 05, 2026

Target

$40.00

Current

$9.14

Performance

—

On Mar 05, 2026, John Baumgartner reaffirmed BRBR with a Outperform rating, targeting 40. Market indecision has kept the 40 target in a holding pattern.

PRMB

Buy

Mar 05, 2026

Target

$28.00

Current

$20.75

Performance

—

PRMB was rated Outperform by John Baumgartner on Mar 05, 2026, with a price objective of 28. The stock is in a wait-and-see zone, leaving the Buy case open-ended.

NOMD

Buy

Mar 03, 2026

Target

$15.00

Current

$10.98

Performance

4.57%

On Mar 03, 2026, John Baumgartner initiated coverage on NOMD with a Outperform rating and target of 15. Neutral price movement of 4.57% leaves room for interpretation.

VITL

Buy

Mar 02, 2026

Target

$48.00

Current

$9.74

Performance

-51.59%

John Baumgartner issued a Outperform recommendation for VITL on Mar 02, 2026, price target set at 48. The market hasn’t rewarded the bullish outlook, exposing uncertainty in the call.

MDLZ

Buy

Jan 08, 2026

Target

$70.00

Current

$62.44

Performance

15.65%

On Jan 08, 2026, MDLZ was evaluated by John Baumgartner, who gave a Outperform rating and target of 70. This case illustrates how a timely bullish rating can translate into tangible gains of 15.65%.

POST

Buy

Dec 01, 2025

Target

$122.00

Current

$80.19

Performance

-19.77%

John Baumgartner rated POST as Outperform on Dec 01, 2025, setting a price target of 122. The stock has underperformed, dropping 19.77% despite the bullish target of 122.

OTLY

Buy

Nov 26, 2025

Target

$20.00

Current

$12.71

Performance

4.78%

On Nov 26, 2025, OTLY was given a Outperform rating by John Baumgartner, with a target price of 20. The stock traded sideways with a 4.78% move, keeping the bullish thesis unresolved.

BYND

Sell

Nov 13, 2025

Target

$1.00

Current

$10.21

Performance

-66.30%

BYND received a Underperform rating from John Baumgartner on Nov 13, 2025, aiming for 1. Investors who stayed short missed an upside surprise of -66.30%.

SMPL

Buy

Nov 12, 2025

Target

$35.00

Current

$9.84

Performance

-49.69%

On Nov 12, 2025, John Baumgartner published a Outperform outlook on SMPL, with a target of 35. Market action contradicted the Buy thesis, as shares slipped to 9.84.

STKL

Buy

Nov 06, 2025

Target

$8.00

Current

$6.50

Performance

68.39%

John Baumgartner on Nov 06, 2025 assigned STKL a Outperform rating, with a price target of 8. The Buy call aligned well with market performance, producing a gain of 68.39%.

KHC

Hold

Oct 28, 2025

Target

$27.00

Current

$24.60

Performance

-3.61%

On Oct 28, 2025, John Baumgartner reaffirmed KHC with a Neutral rating, targeting 27. The neutral call matched muted market action of -3.61%.

HAIN

Hold

Sep 16, 2025

Target

$1.50

Current

$0.62

Performance

-58.43%

HAIN was rated Neutral by John Baumgartner on Sep 16, 2025, with a price objective of 1.5. Investors who stayed cautious avoided some of the 58.43% decline.

THS

Hold

Jul 28, 2025

Target

$22.00

Current

$24.43

Performance

17.00%

On Jul 28, 2025, John Baumgartner initiated coverage on THS with a Neutral rating and target of 22. The Hold stance underestimated the stock’s strength as it gained 17.00%.

UTZ

Buy

Feb 10, 2025

Target

$19.00

Current

$14.28

Performance

4.46%

John Baumgartner issued a Outperform recommendation for UTZ on Feb 10, 2025, price target set at 19. The target of 19 remains in play, though confirmation will depend on future moves.

Frequency Asked Questions

Who is John Baumgartner?

John Baumgartner is an analyst from Mizuho specializing in the Consumer Defensive sector.

What is John Baumgartner's success rate?

John Baumgartner currently has a success rate of +92.03%.

How many ratings has John Baumgartner issued?

John Baumgartner has issued 31 stock ratings so far.

What is the average return of John Baumgartner's calls?

Their stock ratings have generated an average return of +25.84%.

What is John Baumgartner's ranking?

John Baumgartner is ranked #1311 out of 4773 analysts.

What types of ratings does John Baumgartner give?

Their ratings include Buy, Hold, and Sell recommendations, depending on the stock’s outlook.

How can I follow John Baumgartner?

You can follow John Baumgartner by clicking the "Follow Analyst" button on this page to receive updates on their stock calls.

What is the most recent rating by John Baumgartner?

Their latest rating was a Buy on LTH issued on 2026-07-31.